LawforAll

advocatemmmohan

My photo
since 1985 practicing as advocate in both civil & criminal laws. This blog is only for information but not for legal opinions

Just for legal information but not form as legal opinion

WELCOME TO MY LEGAL WORLD - SHARE THE KNOWLEDGE

Saturday, October 24, 2026

M/S Patil Automation Private Limited vs Rakheja Engineers Private Limited on 17 August, 2022

 

1. Mandatory Nature of Pre-Litigation Mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015

  • Core Issue: Whether the statutory pre-litigation mediation contemplated under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (as amended in 2018) is mandatory or directory for commercial suits that do not contemplate urgent interim relief.

  • Holding: Mandatory. Section 12A is imperative in nature. A plaintiff who does not contemplate urgent interim relief must exhaust pre-litigation mediation before instituting a commercial suit. Non-compliance must result in the rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 43, 53, 63, 66, and 84.

  • Ratio:

    "Any other interpretation would not only be in the teeth of the express language used but, more importantly, result in frustration of the object of the Act and the Rules... The right of suit itself will fructify only when the conditions in Section 12A are fulfilled." (Paragraph 43)

2. Suo Motu Power of Courts to Reject Plaints under Order VII Rule 11 CPC

  • Core Issue: Must the power to reject a plaint for non-compliance with Section 12A be exercised only upon an application by the defendant, or can the court act suo motu?

  • Holding: The court can exercise its power under Order VII Rule 11 suo motu at the initial stage before issuing summons if it finds the suit is barred by law (including non-compliance with Section 12A).

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 67 and 68.

  • Ratio:

    "Order VII Rule 11 does not provide that the court is to discharge its duty of rejecting the plaint only on an application... the power under Order VII Rule 11 is available to the court to be exercised suo motu." (Paragraph 68)

3. Inadmissibility of Post-Institution Mediation as Substantial Compliance

  • Core Issue: Can a court cure a violation of Section 12A by keeping the suit in abeyance post-institution and referring the parties to mediation?

  • Holding: No. In a suit where no urgent interim relief is contemplated, there can be no "substantial compliance" through post-institution reference to mediation. The suit must be barred and visited with the rejection of the plaint.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 48 and 63.

  • Ratio:

    "In regard to a suit covered under Section 12A of the Act, namely, in a suit where interim relief is not contemplated, there can be no substantial compliance by way of post institution reference to mediation." (Paragraph 63)

4. Prospective Operation of the Judgment

  • Core Issue: Given the conflicting views among High Courts and the teething problems of a newly amended law, should the declaration that Section 12A is mandatory be applied retrospectively or prospectively?

  • Holding: The declaration of law making Section 12A mandatory is made effective prospectively from August 20, 2022, to protect past transactions, avoid unnecessary reopening of closed matters, and allow stakeholders to become informed.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 83 and 84.

  • Ratio:

    "We declare that Section 12A of the Act is mandatory and hold that any suit instituted violating the mandate of Section 12A must be visited with rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11... We, however, make this declaration effective from 20.08.2022 so that concerned stakeholders become sufficiently informed." (Paragraph 84)

Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati K. Mohammed Arif vs K. Mohammed Fairoz on 5 June, 2025

 


1. Mandatory Procedure for Non-Numbering and Multiple Returns of a Plaint

  • Core Issue: What is the mandatory procedure to be followed by the registry and the trial court when a plaint is returned multiple times for uncured objections?

  • Holding: Under Rule 22 (New) of the Andhra Pradesh Civil Rules of Practice and established judicial guidelines, when a plaint is returned more than three times and objections remain uncured to the satisfaction of the registry, the court must mandatorily list the matter in the open court for a judicial hearing rather than continuing ministerial returns.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 6, 7, 8, 11, and 12.

  • Ratio:

    "Since the trial Court has already returned the Plaint more than three times, exercising its power under Rule-22 (new) of the Andhra Pradesh Civil Rules of Practice, the trial Court ought to have listed the matter for hearing in the open Court and decide accordingly as per law." (Paragraph 12)

2. Judicial Function vs. Ministerial Function in Determining Suit Maintainability at Filing Stage

  • Core Issue: Can the registry or filing section decide the maintainability of a suit or insist that explanations be given directly to the registry before registration?

  • Holding: No. Deciding the maintainability of a suit is a judicial function exclusively vested in the Presiding Judge, not a ministerial function for the filing section. If an objection regarding maintainability is raised, the matter must be placed before the court for a judicial decision.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraph 8, 9, and 10.

  • Ratio:

    "Deciding the maintainability of the suit is a judicial function and not a ministerial function. Consequently, even if there be a valid objection to the maintainability of a suit, the plaint is not to be refused registration nor is to be returned by the Registry but is to be placed before the court, pointing out such objection." (Paragraph 10, quoting Gorripati Veera Venkata Rao v. Ethalapaka Vanaja)

Uttarakhand High Court Ambrish Kumar Agarwal vs Thakur Dass on 8 September, 2015

 

1. Mandatory Requirement of Filing Plaint in Duplicate under Order IV Rule 1 CPC

  • Core Issue: Whether a suit is deemed duly instituted if the plaint is not accompanied by a duplicate copy as mandated by Order IV Rule 1 CPC.

  • Holding: Yes. Every suit must be instituted by presenting a plaint in duplicate. If it fails to comply with sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 1 of Order IV CPC, the plaint shall not be deemed to be duly instituted.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 5, 6, and 8.

  • Ratio:

    "Language of Rule 1 of Order IV CPC would demonstrate that every suit shall be instituted by presenting a plaint, in duplicate... If plaint does not comply with the sub-Rules (1) and (2) of Rule 1 of Order IV, then plaint shall not be deemed to be duly instituted." (Paragraph 6)

2. Consequences of Failing to Carry Out Court-Ordered Amendments within Time (Order VI Rule 18 CPC)

  • Core Issue: What are the legal consequences if a party fails to carry out a permitted amendment within the time specified by the court or within the statutory period of 14 days?

  • Holding: If an amendment is not carried out within the specified or extended time under Order VI Rule 18 CPC, the party shall not be permitted to amend thereafter unless the court extends the time.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 5, 7, and 8.

  • Ratio:

    "If amendment is not carried out within time or within extended time, as the case may be, amendment shall not be permitted to be carried out thereafter, unless time is further extended." (Paragraph 7)

3. Applicability of Order VII Rule 11(e) CPC to Omissions in Duplicate Copies Post-Amendment

  • Core Issue: Does a failure to mirror a permitted amendment in the duplicate copy of the plaint automatically attract the rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11(e) CPC?

  • Holding: No. While the initial plaint must be filed in duplicate, a failure to update the duplicate copy after a court-ordered amendment is a curable defect rather than a fatal flaw mandating the outright rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11(e) CPC. The trial court should grant reasonable time to cure such defects.

  • Key Paragraphs: Paragraphs 8 and 9.

  • Ratio:

    "If amendment is not carried out in the duplicate copy of the plaint, it will not be fatal to the plaint. This defect is curable and it can be cured within such time, as fixed by the court by exercising powers under Rule 18 of Order VI CPC." (Paragraph 8)