Mamidi Venkata Satyanarayana ... vs Mandela Narasimhaswami And Others on 27 August, 1965
1966 AIR 470, 1966 SCR (1) 628
1. Limitation Act (9 of 1908), Arts. 144 and 120 — Hindu Law — Coparcenary Property — Suit for partition and possession by auction-purchaser of undivided share — Limitation — Applicability of Art. 144 or Art. 120 — Adverse possession.
[Paras 632, 633, 636, 640]
- Proposition: The purchaser of a coparcener's undivided interest in a Hindu joint family property is not entitled to immediate actual possession upon purchase; his sole right is to sue for a general partition and for the allotment of the share belonging to his alienor. Even assuming Article 144 applies to such a suit, the possession of the non-alienating coparceners cannot be deemed adverse from the date of sale if interrupted by a formal delivery of symbolic possession. Furthermore, under Article 120, the right to sue does not accrue merely from the date of the auction sale, but only when there is an unequivocal threat by the defendants to infringe the plaintiff's asserted right.
2. Civil Procedure Code (5 of 1908), Order 21, Rules 35(2) and 96 — Execution — Delivery of symbolic/joint possession of undivided share — Validity — Whether a nullity — Interruption of adverse possession.
[Paras 633, 634, 635, 642]
- Proposition: An order for the delivery of symbolic or joint possession of an undivided coparcenary share made under Order 21, Rules 35(2) and 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, though legally unentitled to actual possession, is not a nullity if passed by a court acting within its jurisdiction. Even if the executing court commits an error of law in granting symbolic possession, such an order—until set aside—has full effect in fact and serves to effectively interrupt the continuity of adverse possession claimed by the non-alienating members.
3. Hindu Law — Joint Family — Court Auction Sale — Extent of share purchased — Reduction of share due to birth of coparcener prior to sale.
[Paras 636, 637, 642]
- Proposition: An auction-purchaser at a court sale of a coparcener's undivided share in joint family property acquires only that specific fractional share which subsists in the alienor coparceners at the exact date of the auction sale. If a new coparcener (such as a younger son) is born prior to the auction sale and is not made a party to the suit or execution proceedings, his proportionate share does not pass under the court auction sale, and the auction-purchaser is not entitled to claim his share in a subsequent partition suit.
RATIO DECIDENDI
- On Limitation & Adverse Possession: In a suit for partition and separate possession by an auction-purchaser of an undivided coparcenary share, limitation under Article 144 (if applicable) runs from the date of actual or symbolic possession. An order for delivery of symbolic possession passed by an executing court, even if erroneous in law, is within jurisdiction and operates as a valid factual interruption of adverse possession, providing a fresh starting point of limitation. Under Article 120, time runs only from the date of an unequivocal threat or denial of the plaintiff's right, not automatically from the date of the court sale.
- On Extent of Acquired Interest: The auction-purchaser steps into the shoes of the alienating coparceners strictly as of the date of the court sale; any fluctuation in coparcenary shares prior to the sale (such as the birth of a coparcener not party to the decree) directly defines and limits the quantum of property purchased.
