LawforAll

advocatemmmohan

My photo
since 1985 practicing as advocate in both civil & criminal laws. This blog is only for information but not for legal opinions

Just for legal information but not form as legal opinion

WELCOME TO MY LEGAL WORLD - SHARE THE KNOWLEDGE

Friday, September 18, 2026

Unauthorized Illegal Schemes Run by the TM (Paras 29–32): The defaulting TM (Anugrah) operated outside regulatory bounds by wearing multiple hats—acting as a Trading Member, a Depository Participant (DP), and illegally offering Portfolio Management-like Derivatives Advisory Services (DAS) promising fixed 12% annual returns to induce retail clients to hand over securities. 5. Statutory Bar on Monetary Restitution/Disgorgement by Exchanges (Paras 7, 42–44): Under Section 9(3)(b)(iv) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, stock exchange/clearing corporation byelaws are strictly prohibited from imposing penalties involving the payment of money. While SEBI possesses explicit statutory disgorgement powers under Section 11B, clearing committees cannot invent monetary restitution powers.

Cause Title:
Edelweiss Custodial Services Limited v. NSE Clearing Ltd. & Anr. (with connected Civil Appeals)

Citation: 2026 INSC 941

Court: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)

Bench: J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.

Date of Judgment: September 2, 2026

Headnotes (Important Facts and Points of Law with Paragraph Numbers)

  • 1. Hierarchy and Operational Mechanism of the F&O Segment (Paras 1–5): The structure of the National Stock Exchange (NSE) involves the NSE Clearing Corporation (NCL) at the apex, followed by Clearing Members (CM), Professional Clearing Members (PCMs), Trading Members (TMs), and individual retail clients/investors. PCMs clear trades exclusively for constituent TMs and do not have direct retail clients or proprietary trades.

  • 2. Default by Trading Members and Liquidation of Collaterals (Paras 5–6): Upon severe financial defaults by TMs (such as Anugrah Stock & Broking Pvt. Ltd.) in the Futures & Options (F&O) segment, PCMs liquidated the non-cash collaterals/securities deposited by the TMs to meet market settlement shortfalls, which included securities belonging to individual investors who did not have debit balances.

  • 3. Lack of Statutory Visibility and Privity of Contract (Paras 8, 26, 51): During the relevant period (2019–2021), PCMs maintained consolidated collateral accounts per TM under a gross/weekly reporting framework. They had no legal privity of contract with the TM's individual clients, nor did the regulatory framework provide real-time visibility into individual client debit/credit positions.

  • 4. Unauthorized Illegal Schemes Run by the TM (Paras 29–32): The defaulting TM (Anugrah) operated outside regulatory bounds by wearing multiple hats—acting as a Trading Member, a Depository Participant (DP), and illegally offering Portfolio Management-like Derivatives Advisory Services (DAS) promising fixed 12% annual returns to induce retail clients to hand over securities.

  • 5. Statutory Bar on Monetary Restitution/Disgorgement by Exchanges (Paras 7, 42–44): Under Section 9(3)(b)(iv) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956, stock exchange/clearing corporation byelaws are strictly prohibited from imposing penalties involving the payment of money. While SEBI possesses explicit statutory disgorgement powers under Section 11B, clearing committees cannot invent monetary restitution powers.

  • 6. Introduction of Daily Reporting Regime (Paras 50–51): SEBI's subsequent circular dated July 20, 2021, established a daily disaggregated client-level reporting and margin-pledge mechanism, proving by contrast that such transparent individual tracking did not exist during the subject period of liquidation.

Analysis of Facts of the Case

The litigation arose from major financial defaults in the NSE F&O segment, primarily centered around the defaulting Trading Member, Anugrah. Between late 2019 and 2020, Anugrah suffered massive trading losses and failed to meet its settlement obligations to the Professional Clearing Members (PCMs like Edelweiss). To prevent a broader market collapse and satisfy market dues, the PCMs exercised their contractual right to liquidate the non-cash collaterals that had been deposited with them by the TM.

A group of retail investors—many of whom had voluntarily handed over their securities to Anugrah under high-yield, unauthorized "fixed return" schemes (Gold and Platinum portfolios)—found their valuable shares sold off despite having no direct debit balances with the broker. When the TM went bankrupt, the investors approached the NCL’s Member and Core Settlement Guarantee Fund Committee (MCSGFC), which ordered the PCMs to restitute the liquidated securities (valued initially at hundreds of crores) or face collateral blocking. The Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) upheld this order, forcing the PCMs to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Application of Law by the Apex Court

  • Interpretation of Regulations and Circulars: The Supreme Court meticulously examined NCL Regulations (specifically Regulations 1.7 and 4.5.4) alongside SEBI circulars from 2008, 2016, and 2019. The Court reasoned that the obligations of segregation under these rules applied to the TM regarding its clients, and to the CM regarding different TMs. Because PCMs had no direct relationship with retail clients and operated under a weekly/gross reporting structure, they could not be faulted for failing to filter out individual client positions during liquidations.

  • Distinction in Statutory Powers: The Court applied strict statutory interpretation to Section 9(3)(b) of the Securities Act, contrasting it with Section 11B of the SEBI Act. It held that because the legislature consciously omitted disgorgement and monetary penalties from the permissible punishments under stock exchange byelaws, the NCL Committee acted completely without jurisdiction by ordering monetary restitution.

  • Rejection of Common Law Equity Exceptions: The Court distinguished general restitution precedents cited by respondents (such as Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action or South Eastern Coalfields). It ruled that equitable doctrines cannot override explicit statutory bars, especially when the PCMs committed no illegal enrichment or statutory violation, but merely acted pursuant to valid contractual and risk-mitigation rules in place at the time.

  • Evaluation of Investor Conduct: The Court evaluated the factual reality of the F&O market and the investors' conduct, noting that the retail investors willingly participated in illegal, high-risk fixed-return schemes with the TM. Citing market data and research on retail trading in derivatives, the Court highlighted that chasing exponential, risk-free profits in a highly volatile speculative segment inherently leads to catastrophic losses ("bringing knives to a gun fight").

Conclusion (What the Supreme Court Finally Held)

  1. PCMs had no legal duty or technical visibility: Professional Clearing Members had no statutory obligation, contractual privity, or technological visibility to verify individual client debit/credit positions prior to the implementation of SEBI's daily reporting framework in July 2021.

  2. Lack of jurisdiction to order restitution: The NCL Committee and the SAT erred fundamentally in assuming powers of monetary restitution/disgorgement that are statutorily prohibited under Section 9(3)(b) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1956.

  3. Final Order:

    • Civil Appeal Nos. 31 of 2024, 2187 of 2024, 3179 of 2024, and 7313 of 2024 were allowed, and the impugned orders of the MCSGF Committee and the SAT directing restitution against the PCMs were set aside.

    • Civil Appeal No. 4238 of 2026 was dismissed as not maintainable.

    • Retail investors were left to pursue their independent legal remedies solely against the defaulting Trading Member (Anugrah).

Contradictory and Unreliable Ocular Testimony: Material contradictions and improvements between the initial complaint, the victim's mother's deposition (PW-5), and her statement under Section 164 CrPC render the testimony untrustworthy and uncorroborated. (Paras 5.2.3–5.2.5) Medical and Forensic Inconsistencies: The medical opinion of the examining doctor (PW-9/A) and the FSL report (PW-8)—which detected no semen, male DNA, or blood on the victim's pyjami and noted an intact hymen with no physical abnormality—completely ruled out penetrative sexual assault and falsified the prosecution's theory. (Paras 5.3–5.5) Plea of Enmity as a Probable Defence: The defense successfully established a probable motive of prior enmity arising out of disputes over a shared water connection between the families residing in the same jhuggi cluster. (Paras 6–6.2)

Deepak in JC v. State Govt. of NCT Delhi (Criminal Appeal Nos._______ of 2026 arising out of SLP (Crl.) Nos. 21271-72 of 2025).

Head Notes

  • Contradictory and Unreliable Ocular Testimony: Material contradictions and improvements between the initial complaint, the victim's mother's deposition (PW-5), and her statement under Section 164 CrPC render the testimony untrustworthy and uncorroborated. (Paras 5.2.3–5.2.5)

  • Medical and Forensic Inconsistencies: The medical opinion of the examining doctor (PW-9/A) and the FSL report (PW-8)—which detected no semen, male DNA, or blood on the victim's pyjami and noted an intact hymen with no physical abnormality—completely ruled out penetrative sexual assault and falsified the prosecution's theory. (Paras 5.3–5.5)

  • Plea of Enmity as a Probable Defence: The defense successfully established a probable motive of prior enmity arising out of disputes over a shared water connection between the families residing in the same jhuggi cluster. (Paras 6–6.2)

  • Nature and Scope of Presumptions under Sections 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act: Statutory presumptions of guilt and culpable mental state under Sections 29 and 30 of the POCSO Act are not absolute; they are rebuttable, operate as a rule of reverse burden shifting only after the prosecution establishes foundational facts, and do not dispense with the requirement of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt. (Paras 7.3–7.5.3, 7.7)

  • Standard of Proof for the Accused in Rebuttal: While the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, the accused can discharge the reverse burden or rebut statutory presumptions by a standard of preponderance of probability through cross-examination, exposing gaps, or raising a probable defense. (Paras 7.7–7.9)

  • Protection of Fair Trial and Liberty: Presumptive provisions cannot override the constitutional guarantee of a fair trial under Article 21, nor can they permit a departure from the golden thread of criminal jurisprudence that the benefit of reasonable doubt must always favor the accused. (Paras 7.6, 8–9.2)

  • Final Acquittal: Since the prosecution's case suffered from fatal evidentiary gaps, medical disconfirmation, and the successful rebuttal of statutory presumptions by the defense, the concurrent conviction and sentence by the courts below are unsustainable and liable to be set aside. (Paras 10–10.2)

Analysis of Facts and Laws

1. Analysis of Facts

  • The Prosecution Allegations: The case originated from a complaint by the victim’s mother (PW-5) alleging that her 2.5-year-old daughter was taken by the neighbor (appellant Deepak) to a park, and upon returning, showed signs of distress, crying while pulling her pyjami, and stating that the appellant had put his private part inside hers.

  • Oral Testimony vs. Initial Record: PW-5’s testimony before the court contained sharp improvements and omissions that were absent from the original FIR and Section 164 statements. Furthermore, the private doctor (PW-1) claimed the victim was brought to him at 4:00–5:00 PM, whereas the mother claimed they went at 9:30 PM, exposing irreconcilable timeline conflicts.

  • Medical & Forensic Void: The medical evidence completely dismantled the prosecution’s narrative. Dr. Varnit’s physical examination (as proved by PW-7 and PW-9) found no injury, no bloodstains, and an intact hymen. Crucially, the FSL report (PW-8) confirmed that no semen, no male DNA, and no blood were detected on any of the seized exhibits.

  • The Defense Narrative: The defense established that the parties lived in adjoining jhuggis and shared a common water connection with irregular supply, leading to frequent quarrels. This provided a credible foundation for the plea of false implication out of neighborly enmity.

2. Analysis of Law

  • Limits of Statutory Presumptions (Sections 29 & 30 of POCSO): The Court extensively analyzed the reverse-burden mechanism under Sections 29 (presumption of guilt) and 30 (presumption of culpable mental state) of the POCSO Act. It clarified that these presumptions are not absolute and rebuttable. They require the prosecution to first establish foundational facts beyond a reasonable doubt before the onus shifts to the accused.

  • Standard of Proof in Rebuttal: While the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, an accused attempting to rebut a statutory presumption or prove innocence only needs to establish a case on the preponderance of probability (citing V.D. Jhingan and Noor Aga).

  • Preservation of Fair Trial Norms: Citing Naresh Kumar v. State of Himachal Pradesh and Kali Ram, the Court stressed that presumptive provisions cannot bypass the fundamental norms of fair trial under Article 21. If the prosecution evidence suffers from inherent contradictions and medical disconfirmation, the statutory presumption dissolves.

  • Benefit of Doubt: The foundational tenet of criminal jurisprudence remains untouched—where two views are possible, the one favoring the accused must prevail, and courts must not bow to societal pressure or gravity of the charge when evidence is lacking.

Conclusion

The Supreme Court concluded that the concurrent judgments of the trial court and the High Court erred by mechanically applying the statutory presumptions under the POCSO Act without critically evaluating the total failure of the prosecution's foundational evidence.

  • The medical evidence and FSL report completely negated any form of penetrative assault or injury.

  • The testimonies of key witnesses were riddled with material contradictions, and the defense successfully discharged its burden of rebutting the statutory presumption by exposing the gaps in the prosecution's story and establishing a probable motive of water-related enmity.

Consequently, the Supreme Court allowed the appeals, set aside the judgment and order of the High Court confirming the conviction under Section 363 IPC and Section 6 of the POCSO Act, acquitted the appellant, and directed his immediate release from custody unless required in any other case.

Delay in FIR: The delay of about two days in lodging the FIR does not adversely affect the prosecution case, as a plausible explanation was provided regarding the family's apprehension of public humiliation in a rural background.

 


2026 INSC 958 -
DHANRAJ - VERSUS - STATE OF RAJASTHAN 

Head Notes

  • Delay in FIR: The delay of about two days in lodging the FIR does not adversely affect the prosecution case, as a plausible explanation was provided regarding the family's apprehension of public humiliation in a rural background. **** (Paras 23–24)

  • Deficiencies in Investigation: The failure of the Investigating Officer to conduct any inquiry into the complaints made by the accused regarding false implication due to political rivalry, coupled with the non-production of the sketch prepared with the victim's assistance, casts serious doubt on the basis of the accused's arrest. **** (Paras 27–32)

  • Discrepancy in Medical Evidence: The medical evidence indicating that the victim's injuries were 5 to 7 days old (with pus and maggots present) contradicts the prosecution's theory that the incident occurred on 5th December, 2016, creating a significant dent in the prosecution's case. **** (Paras 33–36)

  • Absence of Scientific Corroboration: The absence of DNA profiling or serological evidence linking the biological material recovered from the victim to the accused-appellant weakens the prosecution's effort to establish a nexus between the accused and the crime. **** (Paras 35–36)

  • Substantive vs. Corroborative Identification: Test Identification Parade (TIP) proceedings are merely corroborative in nature; the primary, substantive evidence for establishing identity is the identification of the accused by the witness in court (dock identification). **** (Paras 41–43)

  • Fatal Flaw in Prosecution Case (Failure of Dock Identification): The failure to get the accused identified by the victim during her deposition before the trial Court—combined with the fact that the accused was not named in the FIR and his name was disclosed to the victim by the police—is a fatal flaw that demolishes the prosecution case. **** (Paras 37–40, 44, 53–55)

  • Duty of the Court: Criminal trials are not adversarial contests; courts and public prosecutors must not act passively and have a duty under Section 165 of the Evidence Act and Section 311 of the CrPC to elicit material evidence necessary for a just adjudication, such as ensuring proper dock identification. **** (Paras 45–48)

  • Final Acquittal: Given that the deficiencies go to the root of the matter, and considering that the appellant has already been incarcerated for over nine years, remanding the matter is unnecessary, and the conviction and sentence are set aside, resulting in the appellant's acquittal. **** (Paras 56–60)

  • 1. Analysis of Facts

    The prosecution's case rested heavily on circumstantial and testimonial evidence, which upon scrutiny revealed critical gaps and inconsistencies:

    • The Incident and Delay: The 5-year-old victim went missing on December 5, 2016, and was later found bleeding from her genitals. The FIR was lodged two days later (December 7, 2016) against an "unknown person." While the Court accepted the rural background and fear of social backlash as a plausible explanation for the delay, the absence of the assailant's name in the initial report placed a heavy burden on subsequent identification procedures.

    • Defective Investigation & Withheld Evidence:

      • The Investigating Officer (IO) admitted to receiving affidavits and complaints from the accused and his family alleging false implication due to political rivalry with a local MLA, yet chose not to investigate them.

      • The IO admitted that a sketch of the suspect was prepared in Jaipur with the victim's assistance, but this crucial piece of primary evidence was mysteriously withheld and never produced in court.

      • The IO acknowledged that the appellant was arrested solely on a "source informer's report" without any concrete foundational link.

    • Medical Contradictions: The medical examination conducted on December 7, 2016 (PW-7) revealed severe injuries (1-inch wound from perianal to vagina) with foul-smelling pus and maggots, with the doctor explicitly stating the injuries were 5 to 7 days old. This timeline directly contradicted the prosecution’s case that the assault occurred two days prior on December 5, creating an irreconcilable temporal mismatch. Furthermore, no DNA profiling or serological evidence was gathered to tie the biological samples to the appellant.

    • The Fatal Flaw in Identification: The victim was never asked to identify the accused (dock identification) while testifying in court. Furthermore, the victim admitted in her cross-examination that the police had gathered men at the police station and explicitly disclosed the name of Dhanraj to her prior to the Test Identification Parade (TIP).

    2. Analysis of Law

    The Supreme Court evaluated the case against established legal principles governing criminal jurisprudence, identification, and judicial duty:

    • Substantive vs. Corroborative Evidence of Identity: Reaffirming the principle in Rameshwar Singh v. State of J&K, the Court reiterated that TIP during investigation is merely corroborative, whereas the substantive evidence of identity is the dock identification (identification in court by the witness). Relying solely on a TIP while failing to conduct an in-court identification—especially when police pre-disclosed the accused's name—destroys the evidentiary reliability of the identity claim.

    • Active Role of the Court and Prosecution: Citing Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh v. State of Gujarat, the Court emphasized that a criminal trial is not a passive adversarial game. Under Section 165 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and Section 311 of the CrPC, trial judges and public prosecutors have an affirmative duty to ensure vital steps—such as dock identification—are not omitted through sheer negligence.

    • Standard of Proof in Criminal Trials: The burden remains strictly on the prosecution to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. When medical evidence contradicts the timeline, identity procedures are vitiated, and scientific corroboration (like DNA) is absent, the benefit of the doubt must tilt firmly in favor of the accused.

    3. Conclusion

    The Supreme Court concluded that the concurrent findings of guilt by the trial court and the High Court were ex facie untenable.

    • The cumulative effect of the medical timeline discrepancy (injuries being 5–7 days old), the fatal omission of dock identification, the police pre-disclosing the suspect's name, and the suppression of the victim's sketch completely dismantled the prosecution's case.

    • Given that the appellant had already suffered incarceration for over nine years, remanding the matter for a de novo trial would serve no purpose since the foundational flaws in identification could no longer be cured.

    • Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the judgments of both the Trial Court and the High Court, acquitted the appellant of all charges, and ordered his immediate release from prison unless required in any other case.