LawforAll

advocatemmmohan

My photo
since 1985 practicing as advocate in both civil & criminal laws

WELCOME TO LEGAL WORLD

WELCOME TO MY LEGAL WORLD - SHARE THE KNOWLEDGE

Friday, May 11, 2012

« The custody of female child aged 9 years, likes to remain with her father , on the petition of the mother the Apex court after interviewing the child fixed 3 days day time custody on three different days as observation period to know the changes of the child when she is with her mother under special circumstances of the case and directed the High court mediation center to report the matter.



                        IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

                         CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

                                      1


                2 SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (C) NO.8160 OF 2011




Meenakshi Khandelwal                          ....  Petitioner (s)

            Versus

Shailesh Khandelwal                                   .... Respondent(s)





                                  O R D E R



P. Sathasivam, J.
1)    By consent of both the parties, the  Principal  Judge,  Family  Court,
Raipur, vide order dated 01.02.2008, in Case No.  170-A/2007  dissolved  the
marriage of the petitioner and respondent herein, solemnized on  11.12.1999,
by a decree of divorce.

2)    On the application of the petitioner-mother, the Family Court  granted
her the  custody  of  the  daughter-Shrestha.   The  father  of  the  child-
respondent herein challenged the said order before  the  Division  Bench  of
the High Court  of  Chhattisgarh  at  Bilaspur.   The  High  Court,  by  the
impugned order dated 09.11.2010 in  F.A.  (M)  No.79  of  2010  allowed  the
appeal filed by the father of the child and  permitted  him  to  retain  the
custody of the child.  In the same order, the High Court granted  visitation
rights to the mother of the child.  The said order  is  under  challenge  in
this special leave petition.

3)    Considering the interest and welfare of the child,  who  is  presently
aged about nine years and being a daughter, we  directed  both  the  parties
including their daughter to appear before us in our Chambers on  23.04.2012.
 All three of them appeared on that day.  Initially, we interacted with  the
child separately and ascertained her views.   She  expressed  her  grievance
against her mother and prefers to stay with her father.  She  also  informed
us that she is comfortable with her father and would like  to  continue  her
education under his guidance  only.   Thereafter,  we  interacted  with  the
petitioner and the respondent separately.


4)    Taking note of the welfare of the child, which is paramount  and  also
the right and entitlement of the petitioner-mother which is  to  be  decided
in this SLP, as an interim measure, we pass the following order:
a)    The father-respondent herein is directed to  take  the  child-Shrestha
      to the Nagpur Bench Mediation Centre on 19.05.2012 at 10 a.m.
b)    The petitioner-mother is permitted to take  the  child-Shrestha  alone
      in the presence of mediators at 10 a.m. and bring her back at  6  p.m.
      to the Mediation Centre and hand over the  child  to  the  respondent-
      father.
c)    In the same way, the respondent-father has to take the  child-Shrestha
      to the Nagpur Bench  Mediation  Centre  on  02.06.2012  and  again  on
      09.06.2012.
d)    On all these dates, the respondent-father has to hand over the  child-
      Shrestha to her mother at 10 a.m. in the presence of mediators and the
      petitioner-mother has to return the child at 6 p.m. to the father.

e)    During these days, mediators are directed to observe the behavior  and
      relationship of the child Shrestha with  her  mother  and  father  and
      submit a report directly to this Court before 30.06.2012.

5)    List on 09.07.2012 as Item No. 201 for consideration of the report  of
the mediators and for passing appropriate orders.


                             ...…………….…………………………J.


                                 (P. SATHASIVAM)






                              .…....…………………………………J.


                              (J. CHELAMESWAR)


NEW DELHI;
MAY 4, 2012.






-----------------------
4